SCI - Non-Experimental Methods Lesson
Learning Targets:
- Identify and evaluate the purposes, strengths, and limitations of case studies, naturalistic observations, and surveys in psychological research, and explain the importance of random sampling.
Courtesy of the AP psychology course and exam description, effective fall 2024. (n.d.). Links to an external site.
Case Studies, Naturalistic Observations, Surveys, and Meta-Analysis
In psychology, researchers use various methods to study behavior and explore different phenomena. Non-experimental methods, such as case studies, naturalistic observations, and surveys, are valuable tools for gathering information for research.
The Case Study
Case studies are among the oldest research methods in psychology, focusing on analyzing one individual or group in-depth to uncover universal truths. While intensive case studies can offer valuable insights and suggest further research directions, it's important to note that unusual cases may lead to erroneous conclusions. Just like in everyday life, unrepresentative information can skew results. The vivid narratives and personal experiences presented in case studies capture our attention. Still, it's essential to remember that while individual cases can provide valuable insights, general truths require other research methods. Clinical psychologists often utilize case studies to create comprehensive client profiles, highlighting the detailed examination they offer of individuals or small groups. Although case studies excel in providing a deep understanding of specific cases, they may fall short when it comes to generalizability, as the unique nature of each case may not apply to the broader population.
Below are some examples of famous case studies in psychology. These examples showcase the diverse applications of case studies in psychology and their contributions to our understanding of human behavior and cognition.
Naturalistic Observation 
Naturalistic observation in psychological research involves recording responses in natural settings to identify purposes, strengths, and limitations. Examples of this method include observing bird migration patterns in the wild, analyzing customer interactions in a retail store, or studying social dynamics in a park. From studying natural behaviors with essential tools to utilizing advanced digital technology and extensive data analysis, naturalistic observation provides valuable insights into human and animal behavior. While it doesn't explain behavior, this method uncovers patterns contributing to a deeper understanding of cognition, communication, and social interactions. By capturing behaviors in their authentic environments, researchers can gather data that may not be ethically measurable through experimental procedures.The Survey
When conducting research to understand the behavior, attitudes, or opinions of a group of people, using surveys can be highly effective. Surveys involve asking participants a set of structured questions, either on paper, online, or through a computer interface, allowing data to be collected from large groups efficiently. It is crucial to ensure that the sample selected for the survey is representative of the population being studied, achieved through random sampling methods such as drawing names or using random number generators. However, challenges such as low response rates, dishonest participants, and wording effects must be considered. Researchers aim to minimize biases by carefully phrasing questions to reduce social desirability bias and pairing surveys with other measurement tools to validate responses.
Meta-Analysis
One important non-experimental method is meta-analysis, which involves analyzing and combining data from multiple studies to draw more accurate and reliable conclusions. By synthesizing findings from various sources, researchers can identify patterns, trends, and relationships that may not be apparent in individual studies. Meta-analysis allows psychologists to gain a deeper understanding of complex phenomena, contributing to the advancement of psychological knowledge and theory.
Random Sampling
In the world of research, random sampling plays a crucial role in ensuring accurate and reliable results. It helps in avoiding sample bias, which occurs when the sample collected is not truly representative of the entire population. For instance, opting for convenience sampling by just surveying your friends at school may not reflect the opinions of all students. To ensure a representative sample, one must select participants randomly, where every individual in the population has an equal chance of being included. Remember, a smaller but random sample is more valuable than a larger, biased one. The key takeaway is that the best way to draw conclusions that apply to a larger group is through a well-executed random sampling technique.
[CC BY 4.0] UNLESS OTHERWISE NOTED | IMAGES: LICENSED AND USED ACCORDING TO TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION