CJ - Types of Sentences Lesson

 

Types of Sentences Lesson

Does Punishment Deter Crime?

Black and White photo of an Electric ChairDeterrence is the use of punishment as a threat to deter or prevent people from committing more crimes. There is debate regarding whether deterrence actually works. Many people from around the world believe that punishments in the United States are not severe enough. They believe this is the reason why there are so many crimes committed each year.  

Capital punishment, or the death penalty, is harsh enough. However, many people believe it takes too long and costs too much money to sentence a person to death. Since the death penalty began in 1930, there have been more than four thousand inmates that have been executed. Although the death penalty seems like a deterrence for cases involving homicide, it has been found that the murder rate has remained the same since its beginning.  

Do you think the death penalty should be outlawed in the United States?  

 

Capital Punishment in Other Countries

Capital Punishment Map of the world

Teal blue: Abolished for all crimes      

Lime green: Abolished for all crimes except under exceptional/special circumstances (such as crimes committed in wartime)  

Orange: Not used in practice (under a moratorium or have not used capital punishment in at least 10 years)    

Red: Retainers of the death penalty in law and practice - 36 (18%)

*Note - Accurate as of March 2015 when Suriname abolished capital punishment.

 

Retribution is a type of sentence, or way of making the accused pay for their crimes. Retribution can occur by sentencing the offender to prison or by providing the victim with actual payment for injury that occurred during the crime. There are many alternatives to serving prison time, including probation. Probation allows people who have been sentenced to continue to support their families while they are paying back the community for their crimes.

Sentences are punishments for those accused of a crime. They are prescribed punishments for crimes and can be found in state and federal statutes.

The 8th Amendment places limitations on the severity of punishments, including cruel and unusual punishments. Cruel and unusual punishments in the United States include: Public humiliation, excessive fines placed on bail, and pain and suffering.

Choose each item below to learn about different types of sentences.

     The Death Penalty     
        

Capital punishment, or the death penalty, is legal in thirty-one states. There are nineteen states that do not have an enforceable death penalty statute. They include: Michigan, Wisconsin, Maine, Minnesota, Alaska, Hawaii,Vermont, Iowa, West Virginia, North Dakota, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, New Jersey, New York, New Mexico, Illinois, Maryland, Nebraska, and Connecticut. The death penalty application is limited to mentally competent people under the 8th amendment of the U.S. Constitution. In 2023, twenty-four inmates have been executed. There are just over two thousand people on death row in the United States.

    
     Incarceration     
        

Jails are short-term lock-up facilities that are located in counties and run by county sheriffs. Inmates that are held in jails include un-convicted defendants awaiting trial. These individuals usually fail to make bail, are being convicted of a misdemeanor, or felons who are required to serve jail time for probation violations. Prisons are long-term penal facilities that are operated by the state and federal government. Most prison inmates are convicted felons serving sentences of more than one year.

    
     Probation     
        

A period of supervision over an accused offender and is used instead of serving time in jail or prison. An offender on probation is ordered to follow certain conditions set forth by the court, often under the supervision of a probation officer. If the offender breaks the rules, the offender is likely to be sent to prison.

    
     ISP     
        

Intensive supervision probation is used for offenders that are required to have additional supervision. It allows offenders to live in the community but under severe restrictions. Oftentimes, ISP offenders are required to meet with their probation officers more frequently. They may also be required to submit to random drug testing. The average ISP caseload is approximately 25 cases per probation officer. Approximately one jurisdiction per state has implemented ISP.

    
     Boot Camps     
        

Those accused can be sentenced to boot camps and live in military-style barracks. Individuals undergo rigorous physical and behavioral training for several months. In most cases, boot camps are reserved for first-time offenders in their late teens or early twenties. Boot camps are designed to instill discipline and hold youths accountable for their actions. Once the program is complete, offenders are re-sentenced to probation. They avoid prison time.

    
     House Arrest     
        

Individuals on house arrest are electronically monitored through an ankle bracelet, which sends electronic monitoring signals back to a parole office. Those sentenced to house arrest must spend much of their day within the boundaries of their home. House arrest can stand alone as a sanction or be used with electronic monitoring. It can also be coupled with fines, community service, and other sanctions. Some offenders are required to wear electronic monitoring devices that analyze an offender's breath to see if the offender drank any alcohol in violation of conditions of the house-arrest sentence.

    
     Community Service     
        

People who are convicted of crimes may be ordered by the court to perform community services or to work for agencies as a substitution for incarceration or fines.

    
     Scarlet Letter     
        

"Scarlet-letter" punishments are used to shame individuals of their crimes. They are generally cheap and provide moral satisfaction in place of traditional punishment. In the past, courts ordered individuals who were convicted of assault or child molestation to publicize their crimes by placing signs in their front yards. Some judges have ordered reoccuring drunk drivers to place bright orange bumper stickers on their vehicles announcing their problem and urging other drivers to report erratic driving to the police.

    
     Asset Forfeiture     
        

Asset forfeiture requires the government to seize personal assets obtained from or used directly in a crime. For example, a warehouse with all its contents may be seized if it was used in a drug operation.

    
     Restitution     
        

Restitution makes an offender pay fines back to a victim, whereas a fine requires an offender to pay money to the government. The idea behind restitution is to make the offender pay the victim back for economic losses caused by the crime. The offender may, for example, be required to pay the victim's medical bills or pay a sum of money equal to the value of the property stolen. The biggest problem with restitution is collecting the money. To enforce restitution orders, a judge can attach, or garnish, an offender's assets or wages. Another way to enforce restitution is possible in cases in which restitution is a condition of probation. If the offender fails to pay restitution, a judge can revoke the probation and incarcerate the offender.

    
     Fines     
        

A fine is common for a first-time offender for crimes involving minor drug possession, traffic violations, and petty theft. In more severe cases, the judge combines fines with imprisonment or other punishments. If the fine isn't paid, offenders go to jail. Fines tend to discriminate against people who are in financial need, such as the poor.

    

 

Civil vs. Criminal Forfeiture

Forfeiture is the deprivation or destruction of rights in consequence of an obligation or condition. There are both civil and criminal types of forfeiture. Civil forfeiture involves taking property without charging a person of a crime and without a criminal conviction. Property can be taken by the government if the police believe it was purchased with illegal profits used to facilitate a crime. The police must show probable cause in order to seize property under the rules of civil law. The owner can reclaim the property that has been seized by filing a lawsuit. At the trial, the burden of proof rests on the owner to prove the property was not used or purchased with illegal funds or used as part of a crime. A criminal forfeiture requires proof the property was gained through illegal activity. A criminal forfeiture also requires a criminal conviction before the property can be seized.  

 

Black and white old photo of a Brewery to represent law enforcement during Prohibition

 

During Prohibition, police inspected equipment suspected of being used to make alcohol; under civil forfeiture laws, police could seize the equipment without having to charge any owners with a crime.

 

Criminal Justice Review

Complete the activity below to review what you've learned.

 

 

 IMAGES CREATED BY GAVS OR OPENSOURCE